Why Thinking Classrooms
Linlithgow Academy school badge

Mathematics Department · Research and evidence

Why Building Thinking Classrooms?

A research-based approach that moves pupils from copying and mimicking to doing the thinking themselves, together, at the boards.

← All topicsStaff guide

What is a thinking classroom?

A thinking classroom is a space where pupils spend most of the lesson actively working on problems: not watching, not copying, but thinking.

Dr Peter Liljedahl, of Simon Fraser University in Canada, spent more than a decade studying the conditions that get pupils thinking. He worked with over 400 teachers and tested ideas in their classrooms. His book, Building Thinking Classrooms in Mathematics (2021), sets out the 14 practices that came out of that work.

The aim is pupils who are more engaged, keep going for longer, and build a deeper, more flexible understanding of mathematics.

A thinking classroom is a classroom that is not only conducive to thinking but also occasions thinking.

Peter Liljedahl (2016), Building thinking classrooms: Conditions for problem solving, p. 364

Three areas of focus

Tasks and problems

Pupils work on rich, non-routine problems with several ways in. They spark curiosity rather than repetition of a method.

Collaboration and structure

Visibly random groups of three, standing at vertical whiteboards. This encourages risk-taking, discussion and sharing ideas across the room.

Teacher moves

Teachers move from giving knowledge to activating thinking: purposeful questions, hints that keep the challenge, and whole-class consolidation from pupils’ work.

The problem it solves

Liljedahl’s starting point was what pupils actually do in a typical lesson.

“Studenting”, not thinking

Observing ordinary lessons, he found pupils doing what looks like learning: copying notes, waiting for the next example, mimicking the method just shown. Very little of it was thinking.

In his words: “By and large students spend most of their class time not thinking.”

The “I do, you do” trap

When a lesson starts with a worked example, many pupils simply repeat the steps. They can get the answers right in the lesson without really understanding why, and the method soon fades.

BTC flips the order: think first, notes afterwards.

What the research shows

The best-known study compared where groups worked. 46 groups in 5 secondary classes (155 pupils, ages about 15 to 18) were given problems on one of five surfaces, and observers recorded how they worked (Liljedahl, 2016).

20sec
Vertical whiteboard
vs
2.4min
Vertical paper

Average time until a group wrote down their first idea. On erasable whiteboards, pupils start almost straight away. On paper, where mistakes are permanent, they hesitate.

Vertical whiteboardThe other four surfaces

Scores are observers’ ratings from 0 (none) to 3 (high), averaged across groups. Hover or tap a bar for its value.

Show all the results as a table
SurfaceGroupsTime to taskFirst notationEagernessDiscussionParticipationPersistenceNon-linearityKnowledge mobility
10+ years

of design research in real classrooms, refined with teachers.

400+

teachers involved through professional learning and classroom trials.

600+

classrooms, from kindergarten to the end of secondary, have used the practices.

Random groups

What he found

  • Groups the teacher chose, or randomised in secret, made no difference: pupils assumed there was a hidden reason.
  • When groups were made visibly random, every lesson, the class changed within two to three weeks.

What changed

  • Pupils were willing to work with anyone.
  • Social barriers in the room broke down.
  • More sharing of ideas between pupils, and less reliance on the teacher.
  • Higher engagement and enthusiasm.

How strong is the evidence?

Worth knowing before staff are asked to change practice. BTC has a practical, classroom-based evidence base, but it also has real limits.

Strengths

  • Built from real lessons with many teachers, not a laboratory.
  • Clear, consistent effects on engagement: starting quicker, more discussion, more participation, more persistence.
  • Teachers who tried it mostly kept using it.
  • Fits well with what we know about retrieval, collaboration and productive struggle.

Limits

  • Most studies are small: for example, five classes in the surfaces study.
  • They measure engagement, not attainment. There is no large trial showing better exam results yet.
  • Most data comes from Liljedahl’s own research, with older pupils, and is published mainly in books and conference papers.
  • Independent studies so far are small, such as teacher case studies.

Our view: BTC is a promising approach with strong effects on engagement and thinking. We will introduce it gradually and gather our own evidence along the way, from pupil voice, Quadrant results and our tracking data.

What changes in our classrooms

Traditional lesson

  • Pupils seated in rows, facing the front.
  • Teacher models, pupils copy worked examples.
  • Individual, silent practice by default.
  • Notes provided by the teacher.
  • Confident pupils do most of the talking.
  • Assessment mostly through tests.

Thinking classroom

  • Pupils at vertical whiteboards around the room.
  • Pupils work it out and discuss; the teacher facilitates.
  • Collaborative thinking in random groups by default.
  • Pupils write their own notes to their future self.
  • Every pupil is part of a group’s thinking.
  • Ongoing formative assessment, including the Quadrants.

The 14 practices

In the order of the book, coloured by toolkit. Teachers start with the first toolkit and add the others over time.

1Thinking tasks
2Visibly random groups
3Vertical non-permanent surfaces
4Defronting the room
5Answering only keep-thinking questions
6Giving tasks verbally, early
7Check-your-understanding questions
8Pupil autonomy
9Hints and extensions for flow
10Consolidating from the bottom
11Meaningful notes
12Evaluating what we value
13Formative assessment
14Grading
What each practice looks like in the room →

How we are implementing this

Professional learning

Staff explore the research, try the tasks as learners, and reflect together.

Classroom trials

We start with toolkit 1: thinking tasks, random groups and vertical whiteboards.

Pupil voice

We ask pupils regularly what is working and what needs to change.

Gradual expansion

Practices are added step by step, always in service of deeper thinking.

Every pupil can be a mathematical thinker.

Building Thinking Classrooms is about creating the conditions where every pupil, not just the fastest, does the thinking that leads to real understanding.

References

  1. Liljedahl, P. (2016). Building thinking classrooms: Conditions for problem solving. In P. Felmer, E. Pehkonen & J. Kilpatrick (Eds.), Posing and Solving Mathematical Problems (pp. 361–386). Springer. doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-28023-3_21
  2. Liljedahl, P. (2021). Building Thinking Classrooms in Mathematics, Grades K–12: 14 Teaching Practices for Enhancing Learning. Corwin.
  3. Liljedahl, P. Building Thinking Classrooms (overview for teachers). peterliljedahl.com
  4. Edutopia. Interview with Peter Liljedahl on thinking classrooms. edutopia.org
  5. Forrester, T., Sandison, C. & Denny, S. (2017). A secondary mathematics teacher’s perceptions of her initial attempts at utilising whiteboarding in her classes. Proceedings of the 40th MERGA Conference, 261–268.
  6. “The evidence for Building Thinking Classrooms is weak”. A critical review of the research base. pershmail.substack.com