BTC in one minute
Building Thinking Classrooms is Peter Liljedahl’s research into what gets pupils thinking, rather than copying and mimicking. The core of it fits on one screen. For the evidence behind it, see Research and evidence.
A lesson on this site
Every thinking task follows the same 40-minute shape, and the teacher notes on each task are written for it.
On a task page
- Show next challenge reveals the challenges one at a time. → and ← do the same.
- Teacher notes (or N) opens the drawer: what pupils need to know, the running order, keep-thinking prompts, consolidation and answers.
- Answers stay hidden inside the drawer, so the projected slide is safe.
- Each topic has an intro task to open it and a later task to stretch it.
At the end of a topic: the Quadrant
A one-page sign-off. Print it, or project it and pupils work in jotters. The Show answers switch fills in worked answers for marking.
Consolidation in practice
“The bottom” is not the weakest group. It is the simplest idea every pupil in the room has reached. Start there so everyone can follow, then climb one layer at a time to the deepest idea anyone reached. Start at the best board and only the groups who got that far can follow.
Worked example: Handshakes
Ten people each shake hands once. How many handshakes? Four boards, about 8 minutes.
- 1Acting it outA group that drew 4 people and counted the lines.
Ask“What has this group done?” Ask someone who did not write it.
Move on“Great for 4 people. Would you want to draw 30?”
- 2A patternA group that made a table and spotted the jumps.
Ask“What did they notice?”
Move on“We could keep adding up to 10 people. But why does it go up like this?”
- 3The reasonA group that worked out each person shakes 9 hands, then halved.
Ask“Why did they divide by 2?”
Move on“Would this work for any number of people?”
- 4The ruleOften no group gets here. Build it yourself, pointing back to boards 2 and 3.
Ask“What would we write for n people?”
Move onName it: this is a rule or formula. Then notes.
Make it work
- Visit 3 or 4 boards, not every board. It is not show and tell.
- Over the weeks, pick boards from different groups.
- Keep it to about 8 minutes. If it runs long, finish the top layer next lesson.
- Bring in the maths words here, as names for what pupils have just done.
Using mistakes
- A common error is worth a stop: “Lots of boards got 90. Why might that be?”
- Talk about the idea, not the group. Never single a group out.
- Frame it as useful: “This is exactly the mistake that leads to the rule.”
The first two weeks
With a new class, start with 3 to 5 non-curricular tasks in a row (Toolkit 1). They have a low floor and no topic baggage, so pupils learn the routines without worrying about getting the maths “wrong”. Each lesson adds one routine on top of the last.
Week 1 · Build the habits
- 1HandshakesEveryone can act it out. No knowledge needed.
RoutineVisibly random groups of 3, standing at the boards, one pen. Explain why: anyone can work with anyone.
- 2Race to 20Play the class first and win. They will want to know how.
RoutineGive the task out loud in the first 3 minutes, with pupils standing round you. Get them to the boards fast.
- 3Squares on a Chessboard“It isn’t 64” starts an argument straight away.
RoutineAnswer only keep-thinking questions. Use the prompts in the drawer, or reply “What have you tried?”
- 4Tower MoveSmall cases lead to a rule. Groups move at different speeds.
RoutineFlow: check a board and give that group the next challenge when they are ready, not when everyone is.
Week 2 · Deepen them
- 5Magic TriangleMany solutions, so every board looks different.
RoutineKnowledge moving round the room: send a stuck group to look at another board, then come back and try.
- 6River CrossingSuccess depends on recording moves clearly.
RoutineRotate the pen. Ask the pupil not holding it to explain the board.
- 7Consecutive SumsBoards range from a few sums to a full rule.
RoutineConsolidate from the bottom. Walk the class from the simplest board to the most general.
- 8Locker RoomEnds with factors and square numbers, a bridge into S1 topics.
RoutineNotes to their future self. Model a good note, then let pupils write their own.
Then switch to the topic tasks. If a class settles quickly, move on after lesson 4 or 5. Keep the other non-curricular tasks for after a test, the end of a term, or a lesson that needs a fresh start.
Our introduction sequence
West Lothian’s revised order for bringing in the practices. Each toolkit is kept as the next is added: nothing gets dropped.
Toolkit 1
1 to 2 weeks- 1Thinking tasksLessons start with a task to think about, not notes to copy.
- 2Visibly random groupsGroups of 3 made in front of the class, often.
- 3Vertical non-permanent surfacesPupils stand and work on whiteboards, windows or wipe-clean sheets.
- 4Evaluate what you valueValue perseverance, collaboration and thinking, not just answers. Group work rubric →
How: introduce all four together. Begin with 3 to 5 non-curricular thinking tasks in a row.
Toolkit 2
2 to 3 weeks- 5Defront the classroomNo obvious front. Desks at odd angles so pupils look at each other, not just at you.
- 6Answer only keep-thinking questionsPupils ask three kinds: proximity, stop-thinking (“Is this right?”) and keep-thinking. Answer only the last.
- 7Launch early, standing and verballyIn the first few minutes, with pupils standing round you.
- 8Foster autonomyKnowledge moves between boards. Pupils learn to look around the room for ideas.
- 9Use flowHints and extensions given to each group when they need them.
How: add these one at a time, in any order.
Toolkit 3
Rest of the year- 10Check-your-understanding questionsQuestions pupils use to check themselves, instead of marked homework.
- 11Consolidate from the bottomBuild up from what every group did, using pupils’ boards. How it works.
- 12Note-makingNotes written for their future forgetful self, after the thinking.
How: develop the closing practices. The Quadrants fit here.
Compared with the book. Liljedahl orders 14 practices in four toolkits. Our version moves “evaluate what you value” into Toolkit 1, so pupils know from day one that how they work matters. Formative assessment and grading build on these over time, and the Quadrants support both.
The West Lothian framework
What we are improving: engagement, enjoyment, making thinking visible, mathematical discourse, pupil-led learning, and skills for life (metaskills).
- Thinking tasks
- Visibly random groups
- Vertical non-permanent surfaces
- Rich tasks
- Social and language success criteria
- Defronting the room
- Meaningful discourse, mathematical language and notation
- Eliciting pupil thinking
- Keep-thinking questions
- Questions to check understanding
- Embed stages 1 and 2
- Evaluate what you value
- Meaningful notes
- Consolidate from the bottom
- Check-your-understanding questions
- Quadrants
- Develop learning intentions and success criteria: content, social and language
Single-indicator rubrics
Staff information. The pupil rubric on Group work stays as it is for now.
The idea
- Instead of a full rubric, show one question with one line: where pupils are now, and where they are heading.
- The indicator changes with what the class needs. Pick the one you saw go wrong last lesson.
- Groups place themselves on the line at the start, and again at the end.
- In time, pupils notice what isn’t working in their group and write the indicator themselves.
Using it in a lesson
- Launch: show the question with the Purpose of learning. Ask what the right-hand end looks like and sounds like.
- During: name it when you see it: “That was considering, not ignoring.”
- End: each group marks where they got to. Ask what moved them along.
- Later: “What should our group work on next?” Let the class choose.
Example indicators
Idea from @buildingthinkingclassrooms, written in our own words.
When a group is stuck, or finished
The aim is flow: the challenge stays just above what the group can do. Too hard and they give up; too easy and they get bored.
Stuck
- Ask what they have tried. Often explaining it gets them moving.
- Use a keep-thinking prompt from the teacher notes. Each task lists the common sticking points.
- Send them to look at another board, then come back.
- Suggest a smaller case: fewer people, fewer discs, a smaller number.
- Still stuck? Give a small hint, not the method, and check back in two minutes.
Finished
- Ask the pupil who is not holding the pen to explain the board.
- Ask “How do you know?” or “Will that always work?”
- Give the next challenge out loud, or reveal it on the board if most groups are ready.
- After challenge 5, ask them to design a harder version for another group.
Questions staff ask
Isn’t it cheating if a group copies another board?
No. Looking at other boards is a key part of it: knowledge moving around the room. The check is whether every member of the group can explain what they took. Ask the pupil without the pen.
What about the pupil who stands back and lets others work?
One pen, passed often, makes that harder. Ask the quiet pupil to explain the board, and check back with them. Random groups mean they are not with the same people tomorrow.
Do the groups have to be random every lesson?
Yes, and visibly. Use cards, an online picker or names out of a hat in front of the class. When pupils see the groups are random, they accept working with anyone, and they stop waiting for the “clever one” to do it.
Do groups need to finish all five challenges?
No. The challenges get harder so that every group always has something to do next. Most groups reach 3 or 4. Consolidation draws everyone together at the end.
We don’t have enough whiteboards.
Windows work well with whiteboard pens, and wipe-clean sheets can be stuck to walls. Any vertical surface that is quick to rub out is fine. Paper on desks is the weakest option: pupils sit down and the thinking stops.
When do pupils write anything down?
At the end, as notes to their future self. Each task suggests a heading. The Quadrant at the end of the topic is their written evidence.
How do these tasks support differentiation?
Through the task, not by sorting pupils. Every task has a low floor and a high ceiling: anyone can start, and the challenges get harder so every group always has a next step. Groups move on when they are ready, and you support with the keep-thinking prompts in the teacher notes rather than easier worksheets. Random groups and vertical boards let ideas move round the room. Consolidation from the bottom then brings everyone together, from the simplest board to the deepest idea. Quadrants differentiate on one sheet: A is scaffolded, B is not, C lets pupils set their own level, D is their own notes. For classes or groups working at Second Level, the Level 2 rows give a simpler version of the same topic, so a mixed room can still share one lesson. Use them as a planned choice for a class or group, not to sort pupils during a lesson: Liljedahl warns that sorting by ability lowers expectations.
What are the Level 2 rows under some S1 topics?
Simpler versions of the same topic, matched to the CfE Second Level benchmarks: friendlier numbers, a picture on every slide, four challenges instead of five, a discussion task (always, sometimes, never; odd one out; spot the mistake; or would you rather), and Quadrants with more scaffolding. Use them with a class or groups working at Level 2, alongside the main tasks if the room is mixed. Pupils see the same topic name, not "Level 2". The benchmark codes are on the topics page and in each task’s teacher notes. Every S1 topic has one, and so do the S2 topics with Second Level content: Circles, Money, Scale, Speed Distance and Time, Reflection Symmetry, Measurement, Patterns and Sequences, Graphs, Volume and Time Zones.
Can I use this with senior classes?
Yes. The same routines work for National 5 and Higher. Start with a non-curricular task, then turn the first question of a topic into a thinking task.